Horrible dating advice, extremely polarizing opinions that she presents as facts. Has no credentials. Boring energy and dull tone. It’s 2025, stop taking dating advice from people who haven’t dated in 5+ years, they have been out of the game too long and have no clue how the dating world currently operates.

Lindsey really is the OG when it comes to all things dating and relationships. I have come back to her pod time and time again for her mix of witty banter and informative guests. Such a gem that keeps getting better!

I’ve been listening to this podcast for years. I love the range of guests Lindsey has on, and the perspective that she brings to the modern dating scene. One of my favorite things about Lindsey is that she playfully and intellectually challenges her guests leaving room for super fun and engaging interviews and topics of conversation that are very rare in the modern dating Zeitgeist. I also love how throughout all the various eras of this show Lindsey rides so hard for the single girlies. She’s a real one. 10.10

I actually love this show more and more as time goes on!! I don’t mind hearing about the baby stuff, I love the dating stuff, married life stuff! Whatever is going on in her life or her listeners lives she talks about in a real authentic and caring way!! I feel like Lindsey actually cares about the people that write her/follow her/do the polls and that is unique and special! I also love the episodes w guests, she’s a great listener/interviewer and loved the episode with her sister so much!! Thanks Lindsey for the entertainment 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻

I used to LOVE this account and podcast. Now, it’s overflowing with baby stuff. Lindsey acts like she is the only woman in the world to ever have a child. Women have been doing this for thousands of years, it’s not new or novel. She makes it sound like being a podcaster AND a mom (gasp!) is equivalent to doing brain surgery or flying a rocket ship for NASA.

was interested in the info each episode purports to offer but it’s mostly the host ts bling about herself interspersed with ads. i don’t care how her hair looks, she needs to focus on the topic or convert it to a personal podcast.

Did Lindsey seriously not know that Mount Vesuvius is in Italy? She actually thought she made up that name? Is this the same girl who said she should just get a job at Goldman Sachs and make $300k because shes having an identity crisis? She sounds very bitter being the breadwinner and having to push through with a podcast that’s irrelevant bc her husband has yet another failed startup.

I’ve been listening to we met at acme for a few years now and it is my favorite podcast. I listen every week! Lindsey is an amazing podcast host who is very open minded and great at facilitating conversations with a variety of guests. Listening to the podcast is like having a conversation with my best friend. I’ve learned so much great relationship advise from Lindsey and cannot recommend this podcast enough.

Thanks for todays episode. I feel like it was so much of what I needed to hear right now

“Don’t go to a kid’s birthday party if you don’t have a kid”? Literally what. I am single and hope to be married with kids one day, but that’s not going to stop me from going to my friend’s child’s birthday party? That’s just making the divide even greater. All the advice on this podcast is outdated, misogynistic and just bad.

Very honest, comprehensive dating podcast out there. Her Instagram surveys are so much fun daily. She’s so inclusive also of every kind of relationship and her advice is universal. If you’re struggling dating in this generation (who isn’t in today’s world?) , you can learn how to navigate and have fun with it to find what you’re looking for. More importantly, you’ll learn how to be honest with yourself and find happiness in the process. It would be nice to have more diversity when choosing guests. It’s cute when it’s New Yorkers. But I’d love to hear about dating from millennials / gen Z from different ethnic groups, religious backgrounds / socioeconomic classes / backgrounds. Might be interesting to consider! I like that she’s lighthearted and not judgmental at all. She literally shares secrets with us like we are in her close inner circle. Without filtering herself. She also constantly says that she isn’t the end-all-be-all and has made many mistakes herself. What more do you want? Ha

Listen to this podcast for the entertainment not the advice. Because her advice is truly the worst. Telling young moms to exclude their friends without kids from their kid’s birthday parties? Insane.

She has proven time and time again that Arab lives (and Asian lives based on that weird spiral she had about her nanny) are worthless to her. She only cares about white lives! Linds, children in Gaza are suffering. Do only white children matter to you?

Love this podcast! Especially the mom coverage transition!

And what was the racist rant about her nanny, who probably is removing herself from a toxic employer?

You can tell she has no media or comms or journalism training and has not taken the time to fine tune the craft of being a podcaster. Her post-marriage brand is all over the place and misaligned with her original branding. Her solos are now a waste of time and essentially a trauma dump for her. She says “like like like” nonstop. Her questions to guests are clearly not well thought out either. Just useless waste of my 30 minutes. Her podcasts are beyond cringe now.

Began listening in 2019, really enjoyed this podcast. It’s gone down hill past year and now is so un relatable. Content is super out of touch. Haven’t been listening like I used to. Find the episodes hard to get through.

Classist, racist, and unlikeable

Alright, this will not be the typical review since I’ve only used this podcast and it’s vast topics to talk with women and make my way into them in the bedroom. Fellas, use this podcast to your advantage. The old saying goes that a fish can’t teach you how to catch fish, well… they can sure give you bait. That is all, thanks for what you do 🎖️

Such solid advice about dating! Empowering for women and gives great advice. I think a lot of what she talks about is exuding confidence and putting yourself and friendships first in dating which I love!! Love that she shares her life and journey in motherhood a bit too. Good balance of the two. Some comments are iffy, so I stopped listening. For example when it comes to money, host always links dresses and clothes in the THOUSAND dollar price range which is extremely out of touch for young people in their dating years, nobody is asking for those. And just some strange comments about what you HAVE to spend on wedding gift etc.

I’m single and 25 and STILL love this podcast!! Those saying it’s changed don’t understand that people evolve and develop over time and so do their topics! Loyal listener and love hearing about the momma content for when it’s my time (years from now)

Lindsay is an amazing interviewer - thanks to her a 3 hour and 45 minute drive zipped by in no time. My wife and I love listening to all of these episodes!

Used to love the pod (and still do except for below) and Lindsey until the episode when she featured abhorrent human being lily walla, who no one had never heard of before, but who I learned on the pod is a PROID animal abuser and horrible parent who put her poor baby dog down after she failed to train and supervise him appropriately (who leaves their dog alone with their child, even the gentlest dog?! What is wrong with you?!) then stated “dogs are just animals, we’ll definitely get another one day”. Just absolute trash. Can no longer support.

This has become almost impossible to listen to. I used to enjoy it. The host lacks self-awareness to an extreme degree and shared her opinions as if they are facts. She should do some actual research before commenting on things instead of just spewing her opinions. She lacks expertise and credibility- unclear why she has a platform. The most recent episode talking about how you obviously want to be the better parent compared to your husband was honestly concerning - who sees that as a competition? If you are lucky to have a spouse who is a great parent, isn’t that a wonderful thing for your family? She seems very self-centered, immature, and spoiled. Either get some more people with actual expertise to interview, do more preparation before your episodes, or retire this show!

I wish this were more relevant to dating still. It has definitely changed as the host has changed I wish she’d stick to topics from prior as that’s who she targets?? Maybe not and it’s turning more into the “we met at baby”. Make a choice and advertise as such.

I’m a guy and I usually listen to business podcasts but I got into we met at acme from a girl at work and I’m hooooked

I love hearing from Lindsey! That’s why I started this podcast in the first place and I want more solos and just more episodes in general. It’s the only podcast I consistently listen to

I used to love this podcast for all the dating content, but it seems like all the episodes are about kids and being a mom now. I get some people may like that, but Lindsay said the podcast wasn’t going to turn into that yet it has.

Lindsay is severely lacking in the intelligence department but thinks she’s smart, which is a dangerous combination. The vast majority of her dating advice is terrible- it’s not backed up by any relationship research and is frankly quite toxic for women. Everything is based off her one and only dating experiences and she is incapable of understanding that nuance exists. She is truly vacuous and cringeworthy to listen to.

This review is for Zachary and Zachary only 😘. More mama content please!

Lindsey is the big sister I never had 🫶🏼. Always the best advice, delivered honestly and hilariously, and in such a relatable way! *Supporting Zachary too* 😏😘

Used to love this pod but I’m very over Lindsey’s interviewing style - she follows a list of questions and always relates it back to her rigid list of rules. I would love to hear more about the guests she has on their podcasts and their expertise or work, instead of “so what do you think of having sex on the third date” or “should you say thank you after a date”. It’s dumb and repetitive, we’ve heard your rules a million times. I do like hearing her personal stories bc she’s very vulnerable and shares a lot about her life and growth. Her life updates at the beginning of the pod are wayyy more interesting than the cookie cutter interviews

I am shocked there are any negative reviews! This podcast has been consistently great since 2017 and I met my husband because of her advice!

Please take this host’s dating advice with a grain of salt. As a therapist listening to this podcast for entertainment purposes, I find myself concerned for the type of advice given here at times. This type of content can be what creates insecurities and rumination in relationships that will eventually lead to other conflicts.

Good guests and fun content- an easy listen!

long time listener and lover of the pod. used the rules to snatch my now husband. I'm really disappointed she gave a platform to colton after what he did to his ex.

Don’t have a maternal bone in my body. I’m 59 and loved Linsey sharing! Aloha, Amy

I came across the podcast a few years ago and used to love listening to it but lately, it’s been brutal. I try so hard to listen every week but for instance, I could only get past the first ten minutes today before stopping because it was that cringeworthy. - Her interviewing style has become very rigid. Lindsey tries to a stick to a specific list of questions instead of having an actual conversation with her guest. Her guests bring interesting perspectives sometimes and she lets opportunities for thoughtful back and forth go to waste. - Unless you disagree with her. Then it’s her way and you are in the wrong. - Lately it’s been all about me, me and me. In every single interview, she relates it back to herself or tells an unnecessary story wasting valuable time with the guest. We don’t need to hear your answers to every single question - that’s what solos are for. - Her advice seems increasingly catered to college kids which may be her audience predominantly.

Lindsey, congrats on the birth

Lindsey! I started listening to your podcast earlier this year. I started with the most current and just now finished your first episode. I always put your podcast on when I’m getting ready, cooking, or just feel like I need comfort. You have come a long way since the beginning. You always say you love a good debate and I have to say there are some episodes I skipped. But, I never lost interest in your podcast. You are killing it! I look forward to having Sundays to listen to the podcast!!!

My wife and I love to take trips together today she looked at me and said I still like we met at acme the most :) five stars

Always look forward to Lindsey’s podcasts each week! She speaks on such a wide variety of topics and brings on diverse guests each week. Her interviews and commentary are so genuine and insightful. Recommend for anyone looking to improve themselves and grow their relationships!

*****

I cannot believe there was an ad this week on natural diamonds being better economically and environmentally than lab diamonds. This is the most out of touch ad I have ever heard. Like do your own research before just accepting money. You sound dumb. To state that mined diamonds help impoverished communities it actually disgusting. It promotes child labor and it’s very dangerous. Another out of touch influencer.

I love Lindsey I’ve been listening to her since college. She asks the best questions and has extremely interesting guests ❤️

I look forward to listening to this podcast every Sunday!! I’m obsessed

Good perspectives shared and Lindsey is an excellent interviewer. Not every guest is my cup of tea, but that’s how a diversity of guests goes! Recommend for any typical single girl or anyone interested in learning more about relationships.

I’m not sure what qualifies this girl to give dating advice…she’s like 30, married, sober and pregnant. She’s pretty boujee and out of touch and not relatable. Not a fan.

I enjoy listening to the episodes and a lot of it has been helpful for my dating journey. However, I think that Lindsey should interview more people who are from outside of NYC, and more LGBTQIA+ folks. A lot of the advice is centered around the experiences of straight Jewish people who grew up in wealthy communities in NYC. While I do believe that everyone has important opinions and thoughts to share, I think that the listeners would benefit from a wider variety of perspectives. The dating and relationship world has a lot of nuance and is not one size fits all. I understand that a lot of the listeners are in NYC, but the advice might be more accessible/relatable to a wider audience if it wasn’t as centered around the dating scene in NY.

This is a wonderful podcast