Podcast like these are the reason the giants will never win anything again.

Really good podcast to listen to if your goal is to get dumber. Ethan is awful to listen to.

I wrote a fairly negative review (with some criticisms) about a year ago. My main complaints were the shows felt messier than in the past, Nick felt like he was just siding with Ethan, and Ethan and Weiss just felt grossly mean towards each other…I’m happy to be back and say they’ve fixed all of this. Their attitudes have shifted, they’ve been more focused with better topics, feedback, and discussion. It can get emotional, but it feels warranted and more with the Giants, not each other. I’ve re-subscribed and excited to keep listening!

🙄

Ethan has literal baby tantrums throughout the show. Weiss can’t pronounce ANYbody on the roster including the coaches. He said Brian DAYBALL so many times last episode I couldn’t take it anymore . Nick is really random and barley speaks but he’s not that bad . The show has zero structure and these guys have no credibility. They only Make podcasts when they feel like complaining - they don’t have any actual football knowledge and breakdown games . Also unsubscribing and then resubscribing doesn’t do anything to help your ratings Ethan so stop saying that. I won’t Be listening anymore . Hope these guys get a clue if they truly want to make giants pods and have people take them seriously

Test

I liked this podcast for years for its honesty about the organization and realist takes on the state of the team. They don’t sugar coat and lay it all out there. But they stopped doing podcasts around Thanksgiving 2023 seemingly because they were mad the Giants won a few games when they wanted them to tank and so Ethan can tweet about hockey 24/7. Not sure why the pods stopped, I miss hearing their weekly takes. Release a podcast you cowards!

That's why the podcast has been on hiatus. Ethan is trash.

You guys should be ashamed of yourselves. You don’t deserve a show. 5 minutes into your show you’re talking about the giants tanking and where they are in the draft and hoping that Carolina sticks with Bryce young. if you’re going to pretend to be football gurus maybe you should know who actually holds draft pics. You’re worse than Colin cowherd saying the late Dwayne Haskins is one of the worst QBs in the league after he’s been dead for over a year. Shame on you guys and your show.

This podcast doesn’t really offer anything but general opinions you can find by searching “Giants” on Twitter. Doesn’t have any analysis or informed views. Not sure what people get out of this? It’s just a poorly informed podcast, no research done, they don’t really know much about football. Other podcasts like Big Blue Banter have more content and actually give an informed view on the giants and provide you with analysis.

Hi, I like the pod and all, you guys are really insightful but a rare low point: referring to animals to describe Jalin Hyatt’s speed? It was both casually and disgustingly racist. And the lack of pushback from the other 2 on the show was also disturbing. It’s one of those moments where I’m thinking “who are these guys and why am I listening to them?” I know every second of every pod can’t be sanitized of problematic content, you’re speaking your mind. But in this case it might behoove you to be more thoughtful. Thanks.

I like the pod and have been a regular listener for a few years. They’re real about the Giants, often blunt about things when we stink and resistant to blind optimism. I don’t think it needed a 3rd host, and it feels like the new guy just echoes Ethan. Sometimes the analysis side gets lost in some personal feelings or previously held takes. Overall, one of the better Giants pods, just gives the feel of a couple of fans talking ball. But please for the love of God pronounce players’ names correctly.

Another podcast of randos acting like they know everything about football. Weird

Great podcast for insightful NY Football Giants discussions.

This is the only Giants podcast I will listen to, been following these guys on twitter for years and typically agree with their views about the team and future of the organization.

Been listening for months, truly think it is the best to listen and stay updated with all things NYG

Really enjoy this podcast and Ethan & Weis’s takes and realism about the team. Have stepped up their game in terms of guests too! Definitely recommend to all Giants fans!!

Really insightful podcast from two knowledgeable Giants fans!

Awesome podcast. Come on you Giants💙

Been listening to these dudes through the dark times, no one’s been bigger fans than these 2. Honest opinions on the team, they really give you a different view on things both good and bad, really fun to listen to. Listen every week! Great for any NYG fan!

This is a great podcast for Giants fan. I’d say hands down the best. It doesn’t go too in-depth with things that can be boring to listen to but they’re also very knowledgeable at the same time and actually go out on a leg to make real takes. Good for all football fans not just gmen fans

The best giants podcast out!! 🔥

Great podcast

This podcast changed my life

Been following NYGdaily on twitter since 2018 great account even during the dark days of the franchise. Great podcast happy to know about It now and downloaded MOJO app 👌

I really love the podcast and all it’s in-depth analysis of the Giants week by week. I highly recommend it.

One of the most informed podcasts about the Giants and a must listen especially after games for analysis. Always love listening to it on the way home from work in the car. Makes the commute go by a bit easier through that NJ traffic! (Mojo contest entry)

A Giants fan since 2005, I listen to NYG Weekly, Talking Giants and Breaking Big Blue. While I love Justin/Bobby and Jordan, I get the best experience from Ethan/Weis. It’s a combination of realistic criticism with fan optimism without too much into stats.

If you’re a giants fan you’ll enjoy listening. Let’s go gmen!!

Been following their Twitter for years now and have recently been listening to their podcast more and more. It’s clear they know their stuff and let out emotions that every giants fan feels, definitely a big fan and would recommend to any other giants fan!

Great spot to check in weekly for all giants news!! Fans need a place like this

Been listening to Ethan and Weiss for years. These guys get it. Great duo that taps into the pulse of this fanbase as we try to climb back into relevancy.

Pretty good overall podcast. Weis is knowledge and has a logical way of looking at the team. I enjoy his takes. Ethan brings the passion and while he often tries to run the podcast, he’s a decent compliment to Weis.

Ethan and Weis are two of the most level headed Giants fans out there.

Great

Definitely my favorite Giants podcast

This podcast has been very solid and informational while covering every important subject. Weis is awesome on Twitter.

Love these boys, NYG daily is one of the only twitter accounts that doesn’t buy into most stupid rumors and drama, this podcast carries that same integrity. Go big blue! -C.Lopez

Been listening for many years! Love the new format where you guys bring in a guest from the opposing team for an additional episode every week! Hoping Daboll and wink can keep these dubs rolling in!

They aren’t super X’s and O’s guys but they are knowledgeable and have true fan reactions to the games and moves of the team

They got me back in to the Giants

There are many good Giant Pods. Giants Insider, Talkin Giants. But they are clean. I love this Pod for several reasons but my favorite reason is they curse like real men talking football.

I’ll give them 5 stars or whatever to not hurt they’re hustle. They are terrible though. Well Ian or Ethan of whatever is. Dude goes on rants that sound like a Speak and Spell that was abused by Daniel Jones in their past. It gets tiring. “GooD QbS lIkE RuSS elAvaTe theIr tEam”. Anything else is an excuse. It’s like every word has to be some hot take. Just a couple of guys with a podcast watching the same games and twitter clips as we are.

Ethan would rather have Josh Rosen running this offense right now, so yea get over it

It’s awesome

Never ever bring on Will Brinson again, he didn’t even let you guys bring the juice

Great podcast overall, but please don’t have Will Brinson on again. Listeners want to hear you two chop it up and analyze the giants, not listen to him babble about the Panthers and NC state for an hour. Guy didn’t let either of you get a word in. I have enjoyed some of the other guests like LPG and Ranaan.

This podcast is awful.

Very repetitive all they talk about is how bad Daniel jones is and how saquon shouldn’t have been picked 2nd overall.

Analysis is generally solid, but the incessant F-bombing make it impossible to listen with my kids or wife around. I don’t want that language polluting my mind either. You just sound dumb, lacking depth and creativity. It’s not cutting edge; it’s stupid. I’ll continue to give you periodic listens to see if you improve, but I hope you’re willing to absorb well-placed criticism, grow in maturity and become a lot more classy in your approach.